• 46°
Hartselle Enquirer

LETTER: Hype-r Inflation is ‘all wet’

Dear Editor:

In the interest of making the whole truth known about inflation, per capita sales tax and real expenses related to the proposed sale of alcohol in Hartselle the following information is offered.

The argument the city has lost 13.2 percent of its buying power due to inflation seemed “terribly misleading” by omitting that sales tax revenue has also increased 13.2 percent due to inflation over the last ten years. So the inflation argument is a “wash out.”

In their most recent letter, HCED appeared to update their revenue projections by implying alcohol sales will level the playing field between Hartselle and its wet neighbors in the area of per capita sales tax. The new estimate calculates to be $2,823 per person in annual alcohol sales. That is $40.4 million (vs. $8.4 million) per year of alcohol sold in Hartselle. Talk about “hype”r inflation, that’s not 13.2 percent. That is 482 percent – can you believe that?

The economic decision on the wet/dry issue should be based on realistic net income projections. As a city-wide group exercise, I invite your readers to calculate their own estimate of how much revenue Hartselle would receive from the sale of alcohol. (multiply the population of Hartselle (14,322) by the average amount spent per person on alcohol multiplied by 6.8 percent which is the rate used in the previous two estimates to cover alcohol sales tax and licensing revenue). Decatur estimated a reduction of $185,000 if Hartselle goes wet; which is $190 per person – if you can believe that.

To see the whole “rosy picture” enforcement expenses have to be considered. Two enforcement officers to enforce the city’s ordinance on the sales ratio of food to alcohol – deduct $80,000. A vehicle and related expenses – deduct $40,000. Professional fees to audit the books of all the new eating establishments to ensure ordinance compliance – deduct $10,000. Additional expenses related to conducting the customary sting operations – even though we know none of the convenience stores in Hartselle would ever sell prohibited substances to underage customers. Deduct $5,000. If alcohol revenue is $150,000 per yr. and related expenses are $135,000 per yr., the net gain is only $15,000. That is 0.14 percent of the city’s proposed 2012 budget – which, by the way, is less than 10 percent of the current rate of inflation.

Now that’s the whole truth. Who do you believe?

Mark Coleman

Hartselle

Morgan County

20 under 40: Trey Chowning

Falkville

20 under 40: TJ Holmes

FRONT PAGE FEATURED

20 under 40: Spencer Bell

FRONT PAGE FEATURED

20 under 40: Shelby Keenum

FRONT PAGE FEATURED

20 under 40: Rachel Howard

FRONT PAGE FEATURED

20 under 40: Mary Virgina Halbrooks

FRONT PAGE FEATURED

20 under 40: Maggie McKelvey

Decatur

20 under 40: Maegan Jones

FRONT PAGE FEATURED

20 under 40: Lindsey Tapscott

FRONT PAGE FEATURED

‘He lets us have sex’: More details emerge on Hartselle man accused of child exploitation 

FRONT PAGE FEATURED

Hartselle church creates Easter-themed escape rooms 

Danville

Family tradition: State livestock show legacy spans generations

Editor's picks

Baseball for Beau: More than $8k raised for scholarship named after Hartselle child  

Falkville

20 under 40: Lela Weeks

FRONT PAGE FEATURED

20 under 40: Kalleigh Thomas

FRONT PAGE FEATURED

20 under 40: Jaime Hatcher

Hartselle

Veteran Hartselle firefighter charged with possessing child porn

FRONT PAGE FEATURED

Cerrowire expansion named finalist in Business Alabama Awards  

At a Glance

Work begins on repairing two bridges over I-65 in Morgan County in coming weeks

At a Glance

Tickets for Morgan County Sports Hall of Fame banquet available

Falkville

Morgan County volunteers celebrated at annual fire department banquet 

FRONT PAGE FEATURED

Man jailed for stealing car from jail after earlier release 

FRONT PAGE FEATURED

Police: Hartselle man encouraged children to have sex inside his apartment

FRONT PAGE FEATURED

20 under 40: Chris Rigoni

x